Broker Carla Calleja with the question: Broker Carla, ayaw pumirma ng kapatid ko. Pwede pa bang ibenta ang lupa?

Broker Carla, Ayaw Pumirma ng Kapatid Ko sa Extrajudicial Settlement. Can We Still Sell the Land?

By Carla Calleja, MBA, REB

Isa sa pinakamadalas itanong sa akin: “Broker Carla, ayaw pumirma ng kapatid ko sa extrajudicial settlement. Pwede pa bang ibenta ang lupa?”

The story (a dramatization)

Three siblings inherited Lola’s lot in the province. A buyer is ready with cash. Two of the siblings signed the Extrajudicial Settlement of Estate. The eldest, Kuya Ben, refused. Maybe he wants a bigger share, maybe he doesn’t want to sell at all, maybe he’s simply hurt.

Then someone suggests a “shortcut”: “Ilagay na lang natin sa dokumento na kayong dalawa lang ang heirs.”

Please don’t. That shortcut can cost the family the sale, the buyer’s money and years in court. Here’s why, and what you can do instead. (Names and details in this story are fictional.)

The short answer

You cannot sell the WHOLE property without every heir’s consent. An extrajudicial settlement needs all the heirs. If one refuses, you can (1) keep talking and try mediation, (2) sell only your own share, or (3) go to court for a partition or a judicial settlement of the estate. An extrajudicial settlement that leaves out an heir does not bind that heir.

What the law says

Rule 74, Section 1 of the Rules of Court allows heirs to divide an estate among themselves without going to court, through a public instrument filed with the Registry of Deeds, published in a newspaper of general circulation once a week for three consecutive weeks. The key word is heirs, all of them. The same rule says no extrajudicial settlement shall be binding on any person who did not participate in it or had no notice of it.

Until the estate is partitioned, the heirs are co-owners. Under Article 493 of the Civil Code, each co-owner may sell his or her own share, but the sale only covers the portion that will be assigned to that co-owner when the property is divided. Under Article 494, a co-owner may ask for partition at any time.

What the Supreme Court said

In Neri v. Heirs of Hadji Yusop Uy, G.R. No. 194366, October 10, 2012 (Second Division), a mother died in 1977 leaving homestead lands in Samal, Davao del Norte. In 1979, her husband and some of the children signed an “Extra-Judicial Settlement of the Estate with Absolute Deed of Sale” and sold the lands. Two children from her first marriage were left out. Two other children were minors, and their father signed for them without court authority.

The Court declared the extrajudicial settlement void, citing Rule 74: “no extrajudicial settlement shall be binding upon any person who has not participated therein or had no notice thereof.” It held that the sale was “valid but only with respect to their proportionate shares,” meaning the shares of the heirs who validly signed or later ratified. The left-out heirs and the minor who never ratified kept their shares, and the buyers became co-owners with them. The Court also held that the excluded heirs’ case had not prescribed.

The lesson: leaving out an heir doesn’t make that heir’s share disappear. It just turns a sale into a lawsuit.

Your options, step by step

  1. Talk first, then mediate. Under Article 151 of the Family Code, a suit between members of the same family (including brothers and sisters) will not prosper unless earnest efforts toward a compromise were made first. Find out why the sibling refuses. Often it’s about the price, the share or the timing, and these can be negotiated.
  2. Offer a buyout. The siblings who want to sell (or the buyer) can buy out the share of the one who doesn’t.
  3. Sell only your own share. Allowed under Article 493, but the buyer becomes a co-owner with your sibling. Most buyers won’t pay full value for that, and the sale should say exactly what is being sold.
  4. File for judicial partition. If talks fail, any co-owner can ask the court to partition the property under Rule 69 of the Rules of Court. If it can’t be physically divided, the court may order it sold and the proceeds divided.
  5. Or ask for a judicial settlement of the estate, especially if there are debts, a will, or disputes about who the heirs are.
  6. Settle the estate tax. The BIR must be paid and an electronic Certificate Authorizing Registration (eCAR) issued before the Registry of Deeds will transfer the title.

About the estate tax amnesty: the amnesty window under RA 11956 closed on June 14, 2025. Bills to extend it to December 31, 2028 have been filed; the House approved its version in December 2025, and the Senate version is still pending as of this writing. Check with the BIR before you file.

What this means for you: checklist

  • List ALL the heirs: spouse, children from every marriage, and the heirs of any child who already passed away.
  • Never sign a document saying you are the only heirs if that isn’t true.
  • Gather: death certificate, title (or tax declaration), birth and marriage certificates of the heirs, IDs, and the latest real property tax receipts.
  • Get a Certified True Copy of the title from the Registry of Deeds and check for annotations.
  • If a minor heir is involved, a parent’s signature alone may not be enough to sell the minor’s share. Ask a lawyer about court approval.
  • Buyers: insist that ALL heirs sign, or that the estate is settled in court, before you pay in full.

FAQ

Can two out of three heirs sell the whole lot?
No. They can sell only their own shares. The non-signing heir keeps his share.

Is an extrajudicial settlement valid if one heir didn’t sign?
It does not bind the heir who did not participate or had no notice of it. In Neri, the Supreme Court declared such a settlement void.

My sibling lives abroad. Does he need to come home to sign?
Not necessarily. He can sign before a Philippine consulate or give a Special Power of Attorney, depending on the requirements of the BIR and the Registry of Deeds.

How long can a left-out heir wait before suing?
The two-year period in Rule 74 does not apply against an heir who was excluded. In Neri, the Court found the excluded heirs’ action timely even though it was filed years after the sale.

Can we just partition through the barangay?
Barangay or family mediation can help you agree. But the agreement still has to be put in a proper public instrument, the estate tax paid, and the transfer registered.

Ask Broker Carla

Licensed brokers help families with inherited property every day: valuing it, organizing the documents, and finding a buyer once the heirs agree. May tanong ka rin? Comment ASK on my Facebook page, message me on Messenger, or email buyrentph@gmail.com with your “Broker Carla, …” question.

Related reads: My brother sold our inherited lot without us. Is that sale valid? · How to check a land title before you buy

This article is for general information only and is not legal or tax advice. For your specific situation, consult a lawyer or a licensed professional.

Sources

Tagged with: