By Carla Calleja, MBA, REB
The story: “Tax dec lang ‘yan, hindi pwedeng ibenta”
Isa sa pinakamadalas itanong sa akin: “Broker Carla, tax dec lang ang hawak namin. Pwede bang ibenta ang lupa?”
Picture Mang Ramon (a dramatization). His family has occupied a lot in Batangas for 30 years. They pay the amilyar every year, but the only paper they have is a tax declaration. A buyer offers cash. One neighbor says, “Tax dec lang ‘yan, hindi pwedeng ibenta.” Another says, “Notaryo lang, tapos na.”
Both neighbors are wrong, and both mistakes can cost a family a lot of money.
The short answer
Yes, land covered only by a tax declaration can be sold. A sale of untitled land in a notarized Deed of Absolute Sale is valid. But a tax declaration is not a title, so the buyer is only getting whatever rights the seller actually has. Before anyone signs, you need to check whether the land can be privately owned at all, whether someone else already holds a title, and whether the seller is the right person to sell. Then the sale has to be taxed and registered properly.
What the law and the Supreme Court say
1. A tax declaration is not a title
A tax declaration is a record at the City or Municipal Assessor’s Office used to compute real property tax. Philippine courts treat it as support for a claim of possession, not as conclusive proof of ownership. Only a Torrens title (an OCT or TCT from the Registry of Deeds) gives the strong protection of a registered title, which serves as notice to everyone.
2. The land must be alienable and disposable
Under the Regalian doctrine in the Constitution (Art. XII, Sec. 2), lands of the public domain belong to the State. Forest land, timberland and protected areas cannot be privately owned, so they cannot be validly sold, no matter how many years of tax declarations exist. That is why the first stop is the DENR’s CENRO or PENRO, for a certification that the land is alienable and disposable (A&D).
3. The sale is valid, and the first buyer is protected
In Radiowealth Finance Company v. Palileo, G.R. No. 83432, May 20, 1991 (First Division), a couple sold a parcel of unregistered coconut land in Surigao del Norte to Manuelito Palileo in 1970 by notarized deed. The deed was never registered, but Palileo took possession through his mother and paid the real estate taxes from 1971 on.
Years later, a finance company won a money judgment against the seller. The sheriff levied on the same land and sold it at auction to the finance company, which registered its certificate of sale and final deed with the Registry of Deeds.
The Supreme Court ruled for Palileo. It explained that the double-sale rule in Article 1544 of the Civil Code, where the buyer who registers first usually wins, applies to land registered under the Torrens system. For unregistered land, “a different set of rules applies.” Registration under Act No. 3344 is “without prejudice to a third party with a better right,” and the Court held that “the mere registration of a sale in one’s favor does not give him any right over the land if the vendor was not anymore the owner of the land having previously sold the same to somebody else even if the earlier sale was unrecorded.” Because the seller no longer owned the land, the auction sale had no effect.
The lesson for families: a genuine, earlier sale of untitled land is respected. The lesson for buyers: registering your deed does not cure a bad sale. If the seller already sold the land to someone else, or never owned it, your registration will not save you. Do the checking first.
Step by step: how to sell (or buy) land with only a tax declaration
- CENRO/PENRO certification. Confirm the land is alienable and disposable.
- Registry of Deeds. Ask for a certification that the land has no Torrens title yet. If a title already exists in someone else’s name, stop and get legal advice.
- Assessor’s Office. Get a certified true copy of the current tax declaration and its history, plus a certificate of no unpaid real property tax.
- Check the seller. Is the declared owner alive? If not, the estate must be settled first (see my article on extrajudicial settlement). Married? The spouse should sign too.
- Survey and inspect. Have a geodetic engineer locate the boundaries and check who is actually occupying the lot.
- Notarized Deed of Absolute Sale. Describe the land exactly as in the tax declaration and survey. Read why notarization matters in this article.
- BIR. Pay the 6% capital gains tax (based on the selling price or the zonal/assessor’s value, whichever is higher, if the land is a capital asset) and the 1.5% documentary stamp tax, then get the eCAR.
- Local transfer tax and registration. Pay the transfer tax at the LGU, then register the deed in the Registry of Deeds’ book for unregistered lands (Act No. 3344, now Sec. 113 of PD 1529).
- Transfer the tax declaration to the buyer’s name at the Assessor’s Office.
- Plan the titling. The buyer can later apply for a title. Here is my guide: I only have the tax declaration. How do I get it titled?
What this means for you
- Sellers: you can sell, but expect buyers to ask for the CENRO and Registry of Deeds certifications. Having them ready makes your lot easier to sell.
- Buyers: you are buying rights, not a title. Price the cost and time of titling into your offer, and never pay in full before the checks are done.
- Heirs: settle the estate first. A sale signed by only some heirs binds only their shares.
Documents to prepare: tax declaration (certified copy) and history, real property tax clearance, CENRO/PENRO A&D certification, Registry of Deeds “no title” certification, approved survey or sketch plan, valid IDs and TINs of both parties, proof of the seller’s marital status, and estate settlement papers if the declared owner has died.
FAQ
Can a bank loan be used to buy untitled land?
Banks and Pag-IBIG generally require a clean title as collateral, so most purchases of untitled land are paid in cash.
Do we still pay capital gains tax if there’s no title?
Yes. The tax is on the sale of real property, titled or not. The Assessor will usually ask for the eCAR before transferring the tax declaration.
What if the seller sold the same lot to two people?
For untitled land, the Radiowealth case shows that registration alone does not beat an earlier valid sale. Read more in Our land was sold twice. Who owns it now?
Ask Broker Carla
May tanong ka rin? Send me your “Broker Carla, …” question. Comment on my Facebook page facebook.com/carlacallejabrokerphilippines, message me ASK on Messenger, or email buyrentph@gmail.com.
This article is for general information only and is not legal or tax advice. For your specific situation, consult a lawyer or a licensed professional.
Sources
- Radiowealth Finance Company v. Palileo, G.R. No. 83432, May 20, 1991 (full text)
- Civil Code of the Philippines, Art. 1544; Act No. 3344; Presidential Decree No. 1529, Sec. 113
- 1987 Constitution, Art. XII, Sec. 2
- National Internal Revenue Code, Secs. 24(D) and 196 (capital gains tax and documentary stamp tax)
Carla Calleja, MBA, REB · PRC License 0021912 · DHSUD Accred. No. 0024330
